Ohio State University Extension Bulletin

Agronomic Crops Team On-Farm Research Projects 1998

Special Circular 166-99


Chisel vs. No-Till Corn Following Soybeans

Dennis Baker, Extension Agriculture and Natural Resources Agent

Objective

The objective of this trial was to determine the effect of tillage on corn yields when following soybeans in a rotation. Farmers in the area have suspected yield decreases due to tillage.

Cooperator:Darke County Farm Fertilizer:75#/A 0-0-60 broadcast
Nearest Town:Greenville125#/A 18-46-0 broadcast
Major Soil Type:Miami150#/A N with herbicide
Drainage:TileHerbicides:5 qt. Extrazine
Previous Crop:Soybeans1/4 pt. Banvel
Soil test:pH 6.4Hybrid:Pioneer 34G81
P 34 ppmPlanting Rate:30,000 seeds/A
K 164 ppm 

Methods

A replicated study using six replicates in a randomized complete block design was planned to determine whether tillage affected corn yields when following soybeans. Individual strip plots averaged 30' x 1,045' in size. The field had been in a no-till corn and soybean rotation for the past four years. The tilled plots were prepared using a chisel plow and disk unit followed by two passes with a conventional disk. Pioneer 34G81 was planted on May 15 into adequate moisture and with adequate rainfall to activate herbicide and move nitrogen into the soil.

Results

Treatment Avg. Yield (Bu/A)
No-till106.10
Chisel138.18

F = 124.5 Very significant differences among treatment means at P = 0.01, CV = 4.1%
LSD (0.05) = 11.6 bushels/acre

Summary and Notes

Emergence was uniform in all plots but as the corn grew, there became a very visible difference in corn height with the no-till being as much as 18 inches shorter. There was a significant yield increase when using tillage on this particular site when planting corn after soybeans.

For additional information, contact:
Dennis Baker
Ohio State University Extension, Darke County
700 Wayne St.
Greenville, OH 45331
(937) 548-5215
baker.5@osu.edu


Back | Forward | Table of Contents