Ohio State University Extension Bulletin

Street Tree Evaluation Project

Bulletin 877-99


FRAXINUS VELUTINA GLABRA 'MODESTO' Modesto Velvet Ash

4415 W. 182nd, Cleveland

Planted: 1958

Site: 10' Tree Lawn

1971 Comments: This tree is a poor selection because of its susceptibility to borers. The city of Cleveland no longer plants this tree because of the borer problem. Although the tree provides a good appearance for six to eight years, it is not long-lived enough for planting in a public area such as this. The borer causes considerable dieback at the top, necessitating extensive pruning, maintenance, and ultimate removal of the tree.

1967 1968 1969 1970* 1997
Height 18.8' 22.3' 22.3' 15.0' 48.3'
Caliper 5.4" 6.8" 7.0" 8.8" 16.6"
Spread 13.2' 17.6' 17.7' 23.0' 47.6'

*Three trees removed.

1997 Comments: This tree is native to the southwestern United States and commonly used as a street tree. The 1971 comments suggest that this tree has been a problem in Ohio; but this cannot be substantiated since the only planting of the Velvet Ash was in this planting. Borers appear not to have been a long-term problem on the site.

Seventy-three percent of the overall planting survived (8 of 11 trees). The 1997 data in the table are based on three trees.

Modesto Velvet Ash

Modesto Velvet Ash


Back | Forward | Table of Contents